So I never did get around to that appraisal/review of our new computer, and I know that there is at least (at most?) one person in the world interested in our findings (thanks for your interest, Jon - you're personally responsible for the next few paragraphs). To recap, we were ready to replace our 5 year old PC recently and decided - for the very first time - to depart from the Windows World and into the Macosphere. We had looked longingly at the 24" iMac's for several months, drawn by their stylish simplicity (Mel HATES cables, and on the iMac the pretty HD screen is the entire computer - there's no separate CPU tower, and only a power cord and the lead running to the keyboard and mouse), the great interface, the promise of a host of creative applications, and the fact that it provided a non-Vista future (I'm not willing to "upgrade" to an operating system that requires 1GB of RAM just for itself). It also helped that the PC-based software I use for video editing has been discontinued as of this release (ie. there won't be a version 9), so there was very little to tie us to the Windows format. The only other stumbling block for moving to a Mac - that your existing software library becomes redundant overnight - is no longer an issue due to programs like BootCamp and Parallels, which let you run Windows software on the Mac too. On top of that, my employer had a staff discount night and we were able to get 20% off Apple's price, so it became a no-brainer.

Where do I start? In short, this is a wonderful machine to use. It is so unlike the PC's that I've been using since the early 90's. I know I'll sound just like the "I'm a Mac" guy on those Apple ads, but you really do get the feeling that there is absolutely no contest between the two formats: they're like chalk and cheese. The HD screen (which again, IS the computer) looks beautiful. The machine starts up and is ready to use in a matter of seconds (maybe 10?). I plugged in the Airport wireless network adapter on the first night and both the Mac and Mel's Windows-based laptop instantly found the network and connected to broadband automatically - no laborious setup required (the iMac has built-in wireless networking). There's a built-in camera and microphone above the screen, hidden speakers below, and the Apple logo - the only branding anywhere - doubles as the receiver for the included Apple Remote. The Remote lets you control your iTunes library, watch movies, watch/listen to podcasts, play a DVD, view online movie trailers or watch a slideshow of any of your photo libraries (complete with auto pan-and-zoom and music). The problem for us is that we don't want to leave the Mac in the study, since it's so much fun as an entertainment centre. Thankfully it's so portable (just pick up the screen, keyboard and mouse) that you can move it about as required: we've had it set up in our bedroom and even downstairs in the kitchen (that's where I'm typing this from actually - and I can keep an eye on Jessica as I type).
The included software is fantastic: Garage Band is a full featured music creation program that lets you create complex, layered music tracks in minutes; it even lets you create Podcasts or a score for your home movie. Things like Comic Life (used below), iPhoto, iDVD, iMovie HD and PhotoBooth are a lot of fun whilst also being pretty powerful. The Mac even has a feature called VoiceOver: if I hit the Esc key while I say (yes, SAY) "Open Browser", the internet browser starts up. If I say "Stew & Dumplings" or "Deb's Mutterings", it navigates to those blog pages instantly. If i say "Check Mail", it will start up the Mail application and download any new emails. You can even have it read blocks of text (web pages, emails etc) aloud to you in a choice of voices. If you say "Quit This Application", it'll do that too. In fact, if you ask "What Time Is It?", it'll tell you that aswell. Pretty neat. What else? Icons for your applications sit in a Dock area at the bottom of the screen (like the Windows Taskbar) and will jump up and down if they have something to alert you to (eg. new mail). If you click a mouse button, every open application is instantly arranged in a tiled manner across your desktop, so you can keep track of things. Press another mouse button and a second desktop is overlayed across your existing one, this time showing all sorts of customisable widgets such as weather, calculators, world time, dictionaries, flight trackers etc: press it again and it just fades away. All the ports and connectors are tucked away behind the screen (and there are lots of them - including Firewire 800 and Optical digital out) and DVD's slot into the right hand side of the screen. Tired of a boring static desktop wallpaper? The Mac lets you have all of your photos cycling through as your wallpaper. Finished with the remote? It magnetically sticks to the side of the iMac for safekeeping. The list goes on - it just feels like Apple have thought of almost everything to make this a pleasurable experience.
In some ways it's completely unfair to compare this computer to our last PC: the PC is a single-core 2.4GHz Pentium 4 with 512 MB RAM and a 19" CRT monitor, whereas the iMac has a 2.33MHz Core 2 Duo with 1GB RAM and a 24" LCD screen. But even with allowances for the PC's older, slower, smaller feature-set, and you compare to what's on offer with current PC's, the Mac experience is so much more enjoyable. It's been a joy to use so far, and there has only been one occasion where it became unresonsive (I think I was possibly trying to do too many things at once - loading a DVD, playing a movie in iTunes, surfing the web etc) - so that's a good start. I know I sound like such an Apple Tragic, but the experience so far - for both Mel & I - has genuinely been fantastic. Amazing to think that - as well as being the most heavily featured computer we have purchased - this is also the cheapest computer we've ever purchased. Based on our early experiences with it, I'd recommend a Mac to anyone looking for their next computer. Mel has already decided that, when she replaces her business laptop later this year (a Toshiba), it'll be replaced by an Apple MacBookPro: and by then Apple will have replaced their current operating system ("Tiger") with a new OS ("Leopard") which is tipped to include a truckload of added functionality. http://www.apple.com/macosx/leopard/

The one drawback of moving to Mac is that I have to relearn a lot of things (keystrokes, folder behaviours, file types etc are quite different): thankfully there seems to be a lot of help both online and built in to the OS and it's applications. It can be frustrating being out of your depth for a while (especially when you were reasonably proficient within the Windows environment), but hopefully the learning process doesn't take too long: I can see that there is so much potential to unlock.
So there you go - these are my first impressions of life on 'the other side'. I may sound over zealous and uncritical, but it's an accurate reflection of our experience so far (which I appreciate could change). Those Mac ads - which I happen to think are terrifically funny but which I know many people find infuriating/belittling/misleading - might oversell the idea that Mac owners have discovered Utopia, but it's only a mild exaggeration. :)
Matt
(BTW, moving to Apple also means that I can someday in the future move up to the industry-leading video editing software, which is Mac-only. "Final Cut Pro" (part of the "Final Cut Studio" suite) is used to make Emmy-winning TV Shows and a number of feature films, and is one of the two editors that you would need to learn if you ever wanted to move into the industry full time (the other being "Avid"). FCStudio has just been upgraded and includes 6 pro applications, for colour manipulation, 3D design, soundtrack development etc, and is a seriously powerful suite. It's not cheap, and I'll be saving for a little while longer before I can afford it, but I found out this week that my YMCA gym membership entitles me to certain discounts at the Apple store, and I can save 18% on - you guessed it - Final Cut Studio! That saving alone would pay gym membership for 6 months, so it's a pretty terrific bonus that they've made available.